Our water, our park, our neighborhood

Protecting Eagle Creek

Union Strong. Westside Rooted. Ready To Serve.

Eagle Creek Reservoir sits at the northern edge of District 11. For the families who live beside it, it is drinking water, a flood defense, and the closest thing the Westside has to a wilderness.

"My connection to Eagle Creek is personal, just as it is for so many of us in our neighborhood. I boat on the waters near Eagle Creek, eat the fish from them, and swim there with my grandchildren."

Carla SimonCandidate, City-County Council District 11

Where it is

Eagle Creek Park and Reservoir

Interactive map data © OpenStreetMap contributors. Drag to pan and use the controls to zoom. The park office is at 7840 W. 56th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46254.

The park by the numbers

One of the largest city parks in the country

  • 3,900Acres of forest
  • 1,400Acres of water
  • 30 milesOf trails
  • 270+Bird species recorded

Eagle Creek Park features more than 1,400 acres of water and 3,900 acres of forest, and it serves primarily as a nature reserve. It holds roughly 30 miles of trails and state-designated nature preserves, and it is Marion County's top eBird hotspot, with more than 270 reported bird species.

The reservoir was not built for recreation alone. After flooding along Eagle Creek in Speedway killed six people in 1957, the city proposed damming the creek. The reservoir that followed was built to provide flood control, drinking water, and recreation, and to preserve the natural landscape inside a growing city. Indianapolis bought 2,286 acres from Purdue University in 1966 for $3.2 million, and Mayor Richard Lugar opened the park on June 10, 1972.

The park is bounded by Interstate 65 to the north and east and by the Marion County line to the west, and the 56th Street Causeway crosses the reservoir.

The preservation areas

The ground that is set aside

Parts of Eagle Creek are not simply parkland. They are preserves and sanctuaries, held back from development and managed for the habitat itself.

Eagle's Crest Nature Preserve

240 acres. It covers much of the park's west side and holds old second-growth mesic upland forest.

Spring Pond Nature Preserve

43 acres. On the east side below 62nd Street, a wet-mesic forest.

Scott Starling Nature Sanctuary

About 60 acres. Dedicated in 1991 by Alfred "Bud" Starling, Scott's father.

Waterfowl Sanctuary

125 acres. Formed from a cofferdam and a flooded gravel pit left behind after mining in the park ceased in 1980. The Ornithology Center overlooks it.

Land dedicated as a state nature preserve carries protection that ordinary parkland does not. That is the difference between a place that is popular today and a place that is still here for grandchildren.

Who works to preserve it

The park has defenders. They can use more.

Indy Parks and Recreation operates Eagle Creek Park, with support from the Eagle Creek Park Foundation.

The Eagle Creek Park Foundation was established in 1979 by the Eagle Creek Park Advisory Committee as a nonprofit 501(c)(3). Its stated mission is to promote, protect, preserve and enhance Eagle Creek Park. Membership dues are its main source of revenue, and that money supports park improvements, trail restoration, and environmental education. The Foundation says it has invested nearly $3 million in the park since 2001, on projects including the West Side Hiking Trails, the Carlsen Aviary, the Earth Discovery Center, and a fitness trail renovation.

The Eagle Creek Park Advisory Committee advocates for the park to the Indy Parks board, and its members have spoken publicly on the water agreement described below.

How neighbors can help

  • Become a Foundation member or buy a Foundation Park Pass. Pass revenue goes to park enhancements and projects.
  • Volunteer, sponsor a project, or make a one-time or legacy gift.
  • Follow the Foundation's newsletter so you hear about decisions before they are made.
  • Show up. Public meetings on the park and its water are where residents have had the most effect.

Eagle Creek Park Foundation Indy Parks: Eagle Creek

The water question

What is actually being decided

In 1971 the city signed an agreement allowing a maximum withdrawal of 19.8 million gallons of water a day from Eagle Creek Reservoir. That agreement, now held by Citizens Energy Group after the city sold its water and sewer systems in 2011, expired on July 1, 2026. About 10 million gallons a day are currently drawn from the reservoir for the Indianapolis water system.

Rather than sign a new long-term deal immediately, the Board of Public Works extended the existing contract for a year, with annual renewals available through 2031, so the city can study the reservoir before negotiating a new 50-year agreement. That study includes a survey of how much water the reservoir actually holds and how much passes through it.

The pressure comes from outside Marion County. A separate deal would send up to 25 million gallons of water a day from the Eagle Creek reservoir and other Indianapolis water sources to Boone County, to supply the 9,000-acre LEAP Research and Innovation District, which includes a hyperscale data center. In May 2026, Lebanon Utilities said it would not build a discharge site inside the park's limits, though other upstream sites remain under consideration.

In a 10-page letter dated March 25, 2026, twenty-one of the twenty-five City-County Councilors raised concerns about the project's effect on Eagle Creek Reservoir and asked Lebanon Utilities to look at options that would keep the discharge out of the Eagle Creek watershed.

Residents who have testified have asked for specific protections: no sharp swings in water level, spring levels kept high enough for fish to spawn, a public dashboard showing how much water is withdrawn, and the city's drought rules extended to cover Lebanon.

Be clear about who decides

The City-County Council does not have the final vote on this contract. It is negotiated by the mayor's administration and approved or denied by the Board of Public Works, whose members are appointed. The councilors' letter was largely symbolic.

What a councilor can do is real but specific: ask informed questions in public, insist that decisions rest on the city's own data, bring residents and experts into the room before terms are set, and keep the pressure visible. That is the job Carla is asking for.

Where Carla stands

Responsible development respects the people and the water around it

Through the Dandy Trail Neighborhood Association, Carla brought the chair of the Eagle Creek advisory board to a neighborhood meeting to speak about preserving the creek and about data centers that may use our fresh water.

"On the Council, I would push for open conversations with our neighbors, seek reliable information, and weigh economic opportunity against the long-term protection of Eagle Creek and our neighborhoods around it."

Questions about water resources, environmental safeguards, transparency, and community impact deserve careful public examination.

Donate Volunteer Read the Full Policy Platform

Sources

Where these numbers come from

Every figure on this page comes from one of the sources below. Each link opens in a new tab.

The park

Who preserves it

The water agreement

These figures were accurate when this page was written in November 2026. Water agreement terms are still being negotiated and may change. If you spot something out of date, email info@carla4indy.com and we will correct it.